Score: 8

"A unique concept with a superb art style"

submission: - colorwars -

date: October 9, 2007

This game is fun, challenging, and has great visuals. Much of that difficulty comes from the controls, which are hard to adapt to at first. Still, it's a unique idea and a decent timekiller, so this is a good game in my book if you have the patience to master the controls.

Score: 9

"A strange and interesting concept done well"

submission: Transmigration

date: July 18, 2007

Although it was very short and simple, I enjoyed it while it lasted, and the superb artwork and animation kept me interested the whole way through. A longer, more difficult sequel would be great.

Score: 9

"So addicting"

submission: Agnry Faic

date: April 29, 2007

I've been addicted to this game since the day it came out. The concept is something I've never seen before and was pulled off very well. It would've been better if it didn't pause whenever a new level started, but I think it works okay this way.

Score: 10

"Great for 30 hours"

submission: 30 Hour Challenge

date: April 2, 2007

Some parts were better than others, but I still liked it. Nate's part had especially great animation. Only suggestion would be to remove the parts that weren't so great, such as the madness one.

Score: 6

"Unlike most sequels, this was better than the 1st"

submission: Black And White Collab 2

date: March 31, 2007

Although some animators, such as Hellion 2, made craptastic parts, there were a few decent parts in this. Aside from that it dragged on for far too long and it wasn't synced well with the songs. Still, it looks like you've improved bunches since the first one came out. Congratulations on the award, I think you deserved it.

Score: 3

"Too many shitty parts"

submission: Want You Bad Collab XD

date: March 18, 2007

There were far too many shitty parts in this. Either kick all the bad artists out next time or have them work their asses off to make quality parts. A few of the animators were okay, but none were too impressive. And the part with Sheik was a blatantly obvious trace.

I also noticed when you responded to one of the reviews you mentioned this being underrated. I personally think this is worthy of a 3.2 score...at most. I don't care how much time work you guys put into this, the result is still disastrous in my eyes.

Score: 6

"Could have been a lot better"

submission: NG Breakout!

date: March 3, 2007

To be honest, the physics were utter crap and it was boring as hell. The graphics and sound were nice, but everything else about it blowed. If you want to see a good breakout game with great physics, search "Wreckanoid" in the portal.

At one point in this game the ball actually got stuck on the side of the stage and I wasn't even able to finish. You're a great artist (which is probably why you got a 6 overall), just not a good actionscripter.

Score: 7

"I'll give you a big, generous 7"

submission: Super Mario bros Z ep 5

date: February 23, 2007

I don't mind the use of sprites, but the way they were used in this didn't appeal to me greatly. Having to press the space bar whenever a character spoke really bored me to the extent of not reading the text at all. Maybe you should get voice actors for your work next time. As for the fighting, I didn't see anything too impressive about it. Mostly just sprites hitting each other in the sky and plummeting toward the earth.

I see not why this did so successfully. The first two episodes of this series were great, but it got old by the third one. I honestly think it deserved around a 3.6 score, mostly for the effort I see you put into it. It was quite generous of me to give you a 7, but next time try something new. Enjoy your fame while it lasts.

Score: 10

"Loved it!"

submission: Salty Swamp 2: Pilot

date: February 21, 2007

Graphics- Great lip-syncing, and I especially liked the eyes.
Style- A new and original style, and an awesome one at that.
Sound- Did Jerma do the voice-acting? That guy's a genius. Again, there was good lip-syncing to go with it.
Humor- It was short, but it gave me a good laugh.

I haven't any constructive advice to give you, so just keep working on it once you've got your new tablet. I've been waiting for it for almost two years now >.<

Score: 10

"Great job!"

submission: NGC Talent Collab

date: February 12, 2007

:) Thanks for the co-author. I really enjoyed working on this one. Some of the parts could've used a bit of work, but I understand this was for both new and old animators.